What if the journal with the highest Impact Factor is not the most influential one?
When researchers evaluate journals for visibility and influence in academia, they use citation-based indicators. But not all journal evaluation indicators work the same way. Where one type is concerned with the number of citations that an article receives, another indicator takes into account the influence and prestige of the journals citing the article.
Some of the important indicators of this kind include the journal Impact Factor and the Eigenfactor Score. These two journal indicators do have differences in terms of calculation and ranking. Just because a journal has a high number of citations, it does not mean that its influence would also be high in the citation world.
In this blog, we shall get acquainted with the concept and calculation of the Impact Factor and Eigenfactor Score. We shall see how these indicators differ from each other and which indicator provides a better indication of journal influence, as well as how these indicators can help researchers make more informed decisions when selecting and evaluating academic journals.
What Is Impact Factor?
The Impact Factor denotes the average number of citations that a journal’s qualified papers receive within one year relative to their publication in the past two years.
In this case, assuming a journal has gotten 600 citations within the year 2025 to qualified papers published in 2023 and 2024, while the number of qualified papers that have been published in these two years is 200, then the journal’s Impact Factor will be 3.00.
What Does a High Impact Factor Mean?
An increased score suggests that articles from the latest eligible issues from that particular journal attract more citations on an average basis. But this doesn’t always imply that each and every article published by the journal is highly influential and scientifically better.
It needs to be noted here that citation practices are quite different for various disciplines.
What Is Eigenfactor?
The Eigenfactor Score is a journal-level measure of citation impact that captures the overall impact of a journal within the citation web.
While a traditional citation count does not take into account the impact of the journal citing an article, citations from highly influential journals have greater weight on the Eigenfactor score of a journal compared to those from less influential journals.
It employs a network-based model similar to Google's PageRank algorithm, which analyses the interactions between the journals rather than counting the citation numbers.
What Makes Eigenfactor Different?
Eigenfactor of journals mainly includes the following features:
- Five-year citation window: It is based on a citation period that is longer than the two-year citation period used to calculate the Impact Factor.
- Prestige-weighted citations: Citations are prestige-weighted.
- Exclusion of journal self-citations: Self-citations of the journal are not considered in the Eigenfactor citation network.
- Total influence measurement: It measures the total influence rather than the average citation number.
- Normalization: Eigenfactor Scores are normalized such that the total of all scores of the journal network under evaluation adds up to 100.
As Eigenfactor calculates the total influence, big journals publishing more research work may have high scores even if their average influence score is similar to smaller journals.
Eigenfactor vs Impact Factor: Key Differences
The two indicators provide different perspectives on journal citation performance.
| Feature | Impact Factor | Eigenfactor Score |
|---|---|---|
| Citation window | 2 years | 5 years |
| Citation weighting | Citations counted equally | Citations weighted by source influence |
| Self-citations | Included in the calculation, subject to separate review | Excluded from the network |
| Measurement | Average citations per eligible article | Total network influence |
| Publication volume | Uses eligible article count as denominator | Influenced by overall journal publishing volume |
| Interpretation | Average citation frequency | Share of citation-network influence |
Why Can Journal Rankings Differ?
Consider two hypothetical journals:
| Journal | Impact Factor | Eigenfactor Score |
|---|---|---|
| Journal A | 8 | 0.3 |
| Journal B | 4.5 | 1.2 |
Journal A is more cited by the recent publications of Journal B on an average basis. However, in terms of citation network, Journal B is relatively more influential than Journal A.
This difference might be due to the fact that Journal B has a more developed citation network or a more influential journal position.
The above statistics clearly explain the behavior of the two journals under different measures without any wrong ranking.
How Does Article Influence Score Help?
Article Influence Score (AIS) adds another dimension to the evaluation since it takes into consideration the size of the journal.
It is calculated based on Eigenfactor Score and then divided by the proportion of articles published in the particular journal in the citation network. The mean AIS in the citation network equals 1.000.
- AIS above 1.00: Average article influence is above the network average.
- AIS below 1.00: Average article influence is below the network average.
- AIS equal to 1.00: Average article influence matches the network baseline.
This is significant since Eigenfactor looks at total influence, while AIS gives the article influence score. The comparison of journals with different publication numbers will make researchers prefer to use AIS over Eigenfactor score.
Which Metric Is Better for Journal Evaluation?
Neither indicator is universally superior. The more useful metric depends on what a researcher wants to understand.
When Impact Factor Is Useful
The impact factor of a journal can aid researchers in studying the citation rate of recent, qualified publications in that particular journal. The metric is especially helpful for the comparison of journals in the same field and in a short time frame.
Limitations of the metric include the sensitivity to the way citations are made and the type of publication.
When Eigenfactor Is More Useful
Eigenfactor is especially useful when considering the influence of a journal across the scholarly citation network.
Its extended citation time frame and weight based on prestige make it especially broad compared to mere citation count.
It is particularly useful for measuring whether a journal is being cited by important scholarly publications.
Should Researchers Use Both?
Yes. Using both journal metrics together can help create a more balanced view of the impact of the journal.
A journal may have a high citation rate, yet it may be less influential in the citation network overall. Conversely, a journal may have a lower citation rate but hold an important position in the citation network.
Multiple measures will allow researchers to distinguish between these two situations.
How to Compare Journals Fairly
In assessing journals, the following process must be observed:
- Journals should be compared across similar fields.
- Year of publication of the metrics must be checked.
- Citation windows and volume of publications should be taken into account.
- Overall and per-paper influence of the journal should be considered.
- The journal’s indexing and publication scope should be checked.
- Editorial policies, peer review, and ethical standards of publication should be reviewed.
Citation-based metrics must complement the process of journal evaluation.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Which one is better – Impact Factor or Eigenfactor Score?
Neither is better. Impact Factor indicates average citations, whereas Eigenfactor Score indicates journal influence within the citation network. Usage of each measure depends on the purpose of evaluation.
2. How do Eigenfactor and Article Influence Score differ from each other?
While the first one measures journal influence, the second one measures average article influence adjusted by publishing volume.
3. Is it possible that a journal has a high Impact Factor but a low Eigenfactor Score?
Yes. The journal can get high average citations per article but lower citation-network influence due to publishing volume and citation links.
4. Is a high Eigenfactor Score evidence of influence of all articles?
No. The Eigenfactor Score indicates journal influence in the citation network. This score doesn't provide information about any article's influence or quality.
5. Where can researchers find the Eigenfactor Score?
Both Eigenfactor Score and Article Influence Score are accessible through Journal Citation Reports for eligible journals.
Conclusion
Knowing the difference between various journal metrics is crucial in evaluating the influence of scholarly works. Impact Factor is an excellent tool to use in assessing the average citation rate of a publication, whereas Eigenfactor Score evaluates the total influence of the journal on the citation graph.
Yet, neither of these two measures in isolation determines the quality of a journal, nor does either of them indicate research quality.
Informed judgment of journals requires taking into account not only citations but also subject area, editing, peer review, and publication ethics.
References
1. Ali, M. J. (2021). Understanding the Eigenfactor™ metrics. Seminars in Ophthalmology, 36(3), 65–66. https://doi.org/10.1080/08820538.2021.1913313
2. Bergstrom, C. T., West, J. D., & Wiseman, M. A. (2008). The Eigenfactor metrics. The Journal of Neuroscience, 28(45), 11433–11434. https://doi.org/10.1523/JNEUROSCI.0003-08.2008
3. West, J. D., Bergstrom, T., & Bergstrom, C. T. (2010). Big Macs and Eigenfactor scores: Don't let correlation coefficients fool you. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 61(9), 1800–1807. https://doi.org/10.1002/asi.21374
4. Jacsó, P. (2010). Eigenfactor and article influence scores in the Journal Citation Reports. Online Information Review, 34(2), 339–348. https://doi.org/10.1108/14684521011037034
5. West, J. D., Bergstrom, T. C., & Bergstrom, C. T. (2010). The Eigenfactor metrics: A network approach to assessing scholarly journals. College & Research Libraries, 71(3), 236–244. https://doi.org/10.5860/crl-71-03-236

